Pin it
This mouthwatering Italian grilled sandwich brings together silky prosciutto, gooey melted cheeses, and fragrant basil in one amazing bite. It turns simple stuff into something special – no wonder it's Stanley Tucci's favorite comfort food that feels fancy yet totally satisfying.
When I first threw this sandwich together, the smell of toasty sourdough with bubbling mozzarella brought everyone running to the kitchen. The trick was going slow, letting all that cheese get perfectly melty while giving the bread time to turn golden and crisp.
Must-Have Components and Selection Advice
- Sourdough bread: Go for something sturdy with a nice crust. Bread that's a day old actually works better
- Fresh mozzarella: Grab those soft, white balls in water. If you can find buffalo mozzarella, even better
- Aged cheese: Try a bold provolone or aged gruyere to add complexity
- Prosciutto: Ask for paper-thin slices with good marbling from behind the counter
- Fresh basil: Look for vibrant, perky leaves without any brown spots
- Butter: Grab unsalted and let it soften before starting
- Fresh pesto: Whip up your own or grab something from the refrigerated section for the brightest taste
Step-by-Step Making Guide
- Step 1:
- Get Everything Ready: Cut bread into medium slices. Make sure your butter's soft. Blot the mozzarella with paper towels to remove excess moisture. Arrange all your stuff before turning on the heat. Warm your pan slowly to medium heat.
- Step 2:
- Stack Your Ingredients: Spread butter on the outside of each bread slice. Start with the grated cheese inside for better melting. Arrange prosciutto in loose waves. Scatter torn mozzarella pieces across evenly. Dot with pesto. Top with fresh basil.
- Step 3:
- Cook It Right: Drop sandwich into warm pan. Push down lightly with a spatula. Keep an eye on the temperature. You want to hear a gentle sizzle. Flip once the bottom turns golden. Cover with a lid for a minute if the cheese needs help melting.
Pin it
I found that putting a lid over the sandwich during the final minute of cooking helps the cheese get perfectly gooey without burning the bread. This little trick turns a regular sandwich into something truly special.
Ways To Make It Your Own
What makes this sandwich so great is how flexible it is: Try different bread types. Swap in other Italian cold cuts. Mix and match your favorite cheeses. Throw in some roasted red peppers. Add a few sundried tomatoes for extra flavor.
Keeping It Fresh
Though it's best right off the pan, you can: Get ingredients ready ahead of time. Keep your grated cheese in a separate container. Slice bread beforehand. Make extra pesto to use later.
What To Eat With It
This sandwich goes great with: A simple arugula salad. A bowl of fresh tomato soup. Some tasty olives. Italian pickled veggies on the side.
This sandwich has become my go-to meal whether I need a quick lunch or want something nice for dinner. It shows that when you use good stuff and pay attention to how you cook it, even the simplest food can be amazing.
Taking It Further
The tricks that make this sandwich so good can work for other Italian-inspired meals too. Once you understand how flavors balance each other – salty prosciutto with creamy cheese, fresh herbs cutting through the richness – you can make all kinds of tasty dishes.
Drinks And Sides That Work
To round out your meal: Try a light glass of Pinot Grigio. Go for sparkling water with a squeeze of lemon. Add some fresh figs or pear slices. Grab some fancy potato chips. Toss a quick green salad.
Party-Ready Ideas
This sandwich shines when you're having friends over: Cut it into smaller bites for snacking. Set up a make-your-own sandwich station. Cook several at once for an easy dinner party. Serve alongside antipasti platters. Pack them for outdoor gatherings.
Changing With The Seasons
Switch things up throughout the year: In spring, add delicate microgreens. During summer, slip in juicy tomato slices. For fall, swap basil for sage leaves. In winter, spread some roasted garlic inside.
Pin it
Though it seems basic, this sandwich really captures what Italian cooking is all about – great ingredients, careful handling, and honoring tradition while making it your own. It reminds us that sometimes the most straightforward combinations turn out to be the most satisfying meals.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Which type of bread holds up best?
- Toasted sourdough or any hearty crusty bread ensures both crispiness and structure.
- → Is pre-made pesto okay?
- Totally! Grab a good quality one if fresh isn’t available.
- → Why include different cheeses?
- Creamy mozzarella melts in, while grated cheese punches up the flavor.
- → Can this be prepared early?
- It’s tastiest when hot and fresh, right out of the pan!
- → What pairs well with this meal?
- Try it alongside a salad or a warm bowl of tomato soup.