Pin it
This mouthwatering sandwich brings together juicy beef, melted cheese, and sweet browned onions between crispy toasted bread slices. It's that perfect comfort meal that combines what we love about burgers and grilled cheese into one amazing handheld treat.
I first whipped these up back in my broke college days when I wanted diner food but couldn't spare the cash. Now they're still my weekend lunch go-to that always wows friends who think I spent way more time in the kitchen than I actually did.
What You'll Need
- Ground beef: Your sandwich base. Go for 80/20 beef which has enough fat to keep things tasty and moist
- Worcestershire sauce: Brings that deep savory kick that makes beef taste even beefier
- Garlic powder: Adds subtle flavor without taking over the whole sandwich
- Butter: Gives your bread that beautiful brown finish and helps your onions get soft and sweet
- Sweet onions: When cooked slow they turn amazingly sweet. Try to grab Vidalia or Walla Walla if you can find them
- Thick-cut sandwich bread: Texas toast works great as a sturdy foundation. Skip the flimsy bread that'll fall apart
- American cheese: Delivers that traditional oozy texture we all want
- Swiss cheese: Brings a subtle nutty taste that works magic with beef
- Yellow mustard: Adds a zingy counterbalance to all the richness
- Salt and pepper: The basic seasoning duo that pulls everything together
How To Make It
- Brown Those Onions:
- Take 4 tablespoons butter and melt it down in a big skillet over medium heat. Toss in your thinly sliced onions with a good pinch of salt and pepper. Turn the heat down to medium-low and let them cook for about 15-20 minutes, giving them a stir now and then. You want them to slowly turn that pretty golden color and get sweet. Don't rush this part. Good browned onions make or break your sandwich.
- Mix and Shape Your Meat:
- In a big bowl, combine your beef with Worcestershire sauce, garlic powder, salt, and pepper. Mix it all together with your hands but don't overdo it or you'll end up with tough patties. Split the meat into six equal parts and shape them into flat ovals a bit bigger than your bread since they'll shrink when cooked.
- Cook the Patties:
- Get a griddle or big skillet nice and hot at medium heat. Drop your patties on and let them cook for exactly 3 minutes on the first side. Flip them over and right away add your browned onions on top, then layer on one slice each of American and Swiss cheese. Cook 3 more minutes until they're safe to eat and the cheese starts getting melty.
- Put It All Together:
- Smear some yellow mustard on six bread slices. Put each patty with its cheese and onions onto the mustard-covered bread. Clean off your cooking surface, melt 2 tablespoons butter on it, and place your open-faced sandwiches down. Cap them with the other bread slices. Let them toast for 2-3 minutes until they look golden, keeping an eye on them so they don't burn.
- Finish Them Off:
- Add your last 2 tablespoons of butter to the cooking surface, carefully turn your sandwiches over, and toast another 2-3 minutes until this side gets golden and crunchy too. The butter helps create that amazing crispy outside that makes these so good. Move them to a cutting board, slice them corner to corner, and serve them right away while everything's hot and gooey.
I always count on Worcestershire sauce as my hidden trick in this meal. My grandma put it in all her beef cooking, and I think it gives that real old-school diner taste that makes these sandwiches extra special. Whenever I make these for family, everyone ends up hanging around the kitchen, pulled in by the amazing smell of those cooking onions.
Fix It Ahead Of Time
You can cook your onions up to three days early and keep them in the fridge. This saves you a ton of time when you're ready to make your sandwiches. Just warm the onions up quickly before you use them. You can also shape your meat patties a day before and store them in the fridge with some parchment paper between them.
Switch It Up
The classic mix of American and Swiss gives you that perfect melt, but don't be afraid to try others you like. Sharp cheddar brings some tang, while pepper jack adds a nice kick. For bread, give sourdough or rye a shot for different flavors. Some folks even throw in some cooked mushrooms or bacon to make these even more indulgent.
What To Serve With It
For that complete diner feel, pair your sandwiches with some crispy fries or onion rings. Add a pickle spear on the side to cut through all that richness. When it's cold outside, a cup of tomato soup makes this comfort food even better. If you want something lighter, go with coleslaw or a green salad instead.
Where This Sandwich Came From
These tasty treats have been showing up on diner menus across America since the 1940s. They cleverly blend two favorites: burgers and grilled cheese. While people argue about who made them first, many think it was Tiny Naylor who ran restaurants in Los Angeles. What makes this sandwich so smart is how it uses browning to build flavor. Both the meat and onions get so much more complex than what you'd find in a regular burger.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What’s the best way to caramelize onions?
Cook onions in butter over low heat, stirring often for about 15-20 minutes, until they soften and turn golden brown.
- → Which bread works best for this dish?
Thick-cut breads like Texas toast are ideal, as they hold their shape and crisp well during grilling.
- → Can I use other types of cheese?
Absolutely! Swap American and Swiss for options like cheddar, provolone, or your favorite kind of cheese.
- → How do I keep the beef patties juicy?
Mix the seasonings in gently, avoid overhandling the meat, and cook on medium heat to lock in the juices.
- → How can I get the bread perfectly toasted?
Butter the bread and toast it on a skillet or griddle over medium heat, flipping carefully for a golden, crunchy texture.