Pin it
This creamy, smooth white garlic sauce absolutely changed homemade pizza nights for me. It's a fantastic switch-up from regular red sauce, packing lots of flavor and a dreamy texture that's perfect for almost any kind of pizza.
I came up with this when my kid suddenly announced she was totally over red sauce on pizza. What started as me just trying to keep the peace is now hands down everyone’s favorite, showing up at least two times a month in our dinner rotation.
Savory Ingredients
- Parmesan cheese: Gives you rich, nutty depth and thickens everything up; if you can, go for real Parmigiano Reggiano for next-level flavor
- Whole milk: Makes things silky smooth; you can use low-fat but it won’t be as creamy
- Dried oregano: Adds that classic Italian vibe—try to get Italian oregano for that extra punch
- Salt: Brings out all the flavors, super important since there’s lots of dairy
- Black pepper: Tosses in some gentle heat to cut through the creamy stuff
- All-purpose flour: Thickens the sauce so it spreads nicely
- Fresh garlic cloves: Can't go wrong with fresh for that real, strong flavor—way better than bottled
- Unsalted butter: Kicks off the base and lets you adjust the salt to your taste
Tasty Step-by-Step Directions
- Lay Down the Cheese:
- After turning off the heat, stir in the Parmesan right away. It’ll melt right in from the leftover warmth. This step keeps your sauce creamy with zero clumps.
- Pour in the Milk:
- Once the flour mixture smells fantastic, start pouring in the milk bit by bit and whisk as you go. Don’t rush—giving it a few minutes helps things get nice and thick. The goal: the sauce should cling to your spoon.
- Mix in the Dry Stuff:
- Whisk flour, oregano, salt, and pepper into your buttery garlic before anything else. Go hard with the whisk to knock out lumps and keep things smooth. Keep at it for another minute or two until everything gets fragrant and paste-like.
- Get Your Garlic Going:
- Toss in your fresh minced garlic into the melted butter and stir it around for half a minute. You’re just looking to make things smell awesome, so keep an eye out—don’t let it color or burn. Turn down the heat fast if it starts browning.
- Butter Goes First:
- Start by melting unsalted butter over medium. Watch it closely; stay away from browning since we want pure butter flavor, not that nutty browned thing.
- Ready to Use or Save:
- Spread it over your dough while it’s still warm for easy spreading. If you’re saving it for later, cool fully and then stash in a tight container.
Pin it
It’s honestly the Parmesan that makes this whole thing sing. I tried skipping it once and wow, everyone could tell. My husband even asked what happened to the sauce. So yeah, don’t skimp on that “aged cheese” flavor if you want the magic.
Store Ahead and Reheat
Make this up to three days before and chill in a tight-sealed container. When you need it, gently reheat on low and add a splash of milk if it’s too thick. The sauce will get much thicker in the fridge since the cheese and butter firm up cold.
Top Toppings
White garlic sauce is the perfect secret base for toppings that can get lost under tomato. My family is all about spinach with feta, shrimp with fresh arugula after baking, or thin potato with rosemary. For a wild combo, go with caramelized onions, goat cheese, and honey after it comes out of the oven.
Fun Twists
Want a herby kick? Add a big spoon of fresh cut herbs like basil or rosemary in the last minute. Looking for spice? Toss in red pepper flakes with your garlic at the start. If you want it extra-cheesy, swap in half provolone or fontina—melts smooth and ups the flavor.
Fix-It Hints
If things turn out too thick, whisk in more milk a splash at a time until it’s just right. Sauce starting to split or look weird? Get it off the burner quick and whisk in cold milk. Never crank the heat after cheese goes in or it’ll separate on you.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → How long will this sauce stay fresh in the fridge?
Keep it sealed tightly in the fridge, and it'll last for 3-4 days. To reheat, warm it slowly and stir in a little milk to bring back its creamy texture.
- → Can I use non-dairy milk instead of regular milk?
Sure, use unsweetened almond or oat milk, but the texture won't be as creamy. Add an extra spoonful of flour to thicken if needed. Don't forget a dairy-free cheese option too.
- → What toppings go best with this sauce?
Great options include chicken, mushrooms, spinach, caramelized onions, artichokes, mozzarella, or goat cheese. Add fresh herbs like basil or rocket after baking for extra flavor.
- → Can I make this sauce ahead of time?
Yes! Cook it up a couple of days before, refrigerate, and gently reheat when needed. If it thickens, just whisk in some warm milk as you heat it up.
- → How can I tweak the thickness of the sauce?
For a thinner consistency, stir in small amounts of milk until it's just right. If you prefer it thicker, let it cook longer or mix in a bit more roux made of butter and flour.
- → Is this sauce freezer-friendly?
Not really. Freezing can mess with the texture, making it separate and grainy. Stick to making it fresh or keeping it in the fridge for shorter storage.