Pin it
Take regular pizza to new heights with a silky garlic topping that's better than what you'd get at fancy Italian spots. This fancy version mixes a homemade white sauce with top-notch cheeses and herbs, building flavor layers that make each mouthful special. The smooth combo of creamy sauce with melted cheese makes for a pizza you won't forget.
I've tweaked this recipe during many pizza nights, and I've seen folks who swear they "only eat red sauce pizza" change their minds right away. There's something truly special about how the garlic sauce mingles with the melted cheese.
Essential Ingredient Picks
- High-quality Butter: Go for European unsalted butter to make an extra rich sauce base.
- Full-fat Milk: This ensures your sauce turns out velvety and lump-free.
- Raw Garlic: Pick firm, nearby-grown garlic bulbs for the strongest flavor punch.
- Mature Parmesan: Grate it yourself for genuine richness that lifts the whole dish.
- Solid Mozzarella: The low-moisture type keeps your crust crisp and melts just right.
- Garden Basil: Look for vivid green leaves to add color pop and freshness.
Crafting Outstanding Pizza
- Base Preparation:
- Start by melting butter on medium-low until fully liquid without browning. Slowly add flour while constantly whisking for a smooth mix. Keep stirring for exactly 2 minutes to build flavor but don't let it brown.
- Getting The Right Feel:
- Drizzle cold milk in slowly as you whisk hard to keep lumps away. Keep stirring while the sauce gets thicker, watching for tiny bubbles at the edges. Cook until the sauce nicely coats a spoon.
- Adding Taste Layers:
- Mix in chopped garlic and spices once the sauce is thick enough. Take it off the heat before adding Parmesan, letting the leftover warmth melt the cheese slowly.
- Putting It Together:
- Spread a thin, even layer of sauce with a flat knife, leaving a small edge bare. Layer your cheeses smartly, with mozzarella on the bottom and Parmesan on top.
- Finishing Touch:
- Bake at 450°F until the edges turn golden and cheese gets lovely brown spots. Sprinkle with thinly sliced fresh basil right before you serve.
Pin it
After making this pizza so many times, I've learned that how you make the sauce really matters. At one dinner party, I rushed the butter-flour mix and got lumps that wouldn't go away no matter how much I whisked. Now I treat making the sauce like a calming ritual, paying close attention to all the little changes in how it looks and feels.
Smart Serving Ideas
Show off this tasty creation on a wooden board with some fresh basil and a light drizzle of good olive oil. Put whole basil leaves in the middle and sprinkle cut bits around the edges for a nice look. For fancy gatherings, cut it into little squares and pass them around topped with tiny greens.
Fun Twists To Try
Play with this basic recipe by mixing up the cheeses - maybe add fontina for extra creaminess or smoked mozzarella for deeper flavor. Make a fancy version with a splash of truffle oil in the sauce. If you love garlic, tuck some roasted cloves between the cheese layers. You could also try adding some browned onions or cooked mushrooms for more flavor.
Keeping It Fresh
Your leftover sauce will stay good in a sealed container for about three days. Warm it up slowly on low heat, adding a bit of warm milk to bring back its smoothness. For best results, make and bake your pizza just before eating. If needed, warm leftover pizza on a hot pizza stone at 375°F to get back that fresh-baked texture.
Party Planning Pointers
Set up a make-your-own pizza spot with small bowls of toppings so guests can customize their slices. Make extra garlic sauce because everyone always wants more. Think about offering both regular and wheat crust choices. Organize a smooth workflow when you're making several pizzas.
Pin it
After working on this white pizza through many test nights, it's now our go-to Friday family meal. The way it brings together simple comfort food with fancy cooking makes something truly special. Whether it's just for family dinner or a nice get-together, this pizza shows how careful prep and good ingredients can turn a basic dish into something amazing.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Is it okay to prep the sauce earlier?
- Definitely! You can store it in the fridge for up to 5 days in a sealed container. Just warm it up before using!
- → Why pick low-moisture mozzarella?
- It melts more evenly, avoids extra liquid on the pizza, and gives that perfect stretchy cheese texture everyone loves.
- → Can I freeze leftover white sauce?
- You can, but freezing cream sauces may change their consistency. It's better fresh or refrigerated for a few days.
- → How do I make my crust super crispy?
- Heat your oven to 450°F, brush olive oil on the crust before toppings, and use a pizza stone for even baking.
- → What other toppings go well with this pizza?
- Try roasted garlic, spinach, mushrooms, chicken, or artichokes—but stick to dry toppings to avoid sogginess!