Pin it
I got hooked on Sticky Toffee Pudding during a wet afternoon in London and I've been whipping it up ever since. There's something truly special when that hot toffee sauce sinks into the soft date cake. My kitchen gets filled with the most amazing buttery smell as it cooks. It's now my favorite treat when I want to wow everyone at the table.
The Wonder of This Timeless Sweet Treat
Anyone who tries this at my place always wants to know how to make it. The moist sponge gets its incredible softness from dates, and pouring that warm sauce over it turns everything into pure bliss. These days my little girl asks for this instead of regular birthday cake. When vanilla ice cream starts melting on the hot pudding, it's just unbeatable.
Three Key Components
- The base layer: This date-filled cake comes out wonderfully soft and juicy every single time. The dates actually dissolve into the mix leaving little spots of sweet goodness.
- The finishing touch: My sauce turns out shiny and smooth, seeping all the way through each mouthful.
- Great companions: Add some fresh whipped cream or a scoop of vanilla ice cream to make it even better. I sometimes throw on some chopped nuts for a bit of crunch.
Pick Quality Dates
Over time I've figured out that spending extra on proper Medjool dates really changes everything. They're fatter and sweeter which really boosts the cake's feel. I occasionally toss in a handful of dried figs for something different. Just make sure you soak them properly in hot water until they're completely soft and ready to blend into your mixture.
Creating Your Dessert
- Starting Off
- I begin by cutting up my dates and giving them a nice soak with baking soda and hot water. This 15-minute rest is why my cake turns out so incredibly moist.
- Prep Work
- During the date soak, I mix all my dry stuff together. Just simple flour, baking powder and a little salt.
- Mixing Magic
- Then comes the fun part - beating butter and brown sugar till it's super fluffy. After that, the eggs and vanilla go in.
- Combining Everything
- Once the dates are ready, I carefully mix it all together. The batter looks so smooth at this point.
- Baking Time
- It all goes into my trusty pan and into a 350°F oven. You won't believe how good your house will smell.
- Making The Sauce
- While it's cooking, I work on that gorgeous toffee sauce. Just mix butter, brown sugar and cream until it turns golden.
- Last Steps
- After cooling briefly, I pour warm sauce all over it. It's absolutely delicious.
Storing Your Sweet Creation
I always remind friends this dessert tastes best when it's warm. Any leftover portions can go in the fridge for about 4 days. Just remember to warm each piece before eating. I always keep some sauce separate to pour over each serving when reheating. Top with fresh ice cream and it's just as good as when you first made it.
Mistakes to Avoid
- Always soak your dates: I found out the hard way that skipping this step ruins the texture completely.
- Don't overmix: I just stir until everything comes together. Too much mixing makes the pudding tough.
- Check it early: I start looking at mine after 25 minutes. You want the toothpick clean but the middle should still feel soft.
- Serve it hot: This isn't meant to be eaten cold. The flavor just isn't right unless it's nice and warm.
Smart Shortcuts
- Buy the best: Those fat Medjool dates cost more but they're worth every penny for the taste they bring.
- Try new tastes: I sometimes add a bit of ginger or cinnamon to the mix. My guy loves when I pour a bit of whiskey into the sauce.
- Prep beforehand: When friends come over, I often bake this a day early. It warms up perfectly.
- Crock pot version: On crazy days I throw this in my slow cooker. It turns out super moist after about 3 hours on low.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why use baking soda on dates?
Soda water makes the dates super soft, adding a deeper caramel flavor to the cake. It also helps give that perfectly moist texture.
- → Can I prep this ahead?
Absolutely! Make the cake and sauce in advance, then warm them up before serving. Easy to prep for guests.
- → What’s the best way to keep leftovers?
You can cover the cake and leave it at room temperature for two days, or pop it in the fridge for up to five days. Heat the sauce gently when ready to enjoy it again.
- → What goes well with it?
Try vanilla ice cream, freshly whipped cream, or drizzle extra warm sauce on top. The combo of warm cake and cold ice cream is heavenly.
- → Why does the butter need to be soft?
Soft butter mixes with sugar more smoothly, giving the cake that fluffy, melt-in-your-mouth texture we all love.