Pin it
If you're looking for a dessert that looks fancy but is really a breeze to make, this Italian Love Cake is just the thing. It pretty much does all the work for you in the oven, separating into beautiful layers you didn't even have to try for. That chocolate base paired with the creamy ricotta middle is a total knockout, and everyone always wants to know how you pulled it off.
The first time I baked this, it was for my husband’s birthday because his Nonna talked about it as his childhood fave. The grin he had at the first forkful totally sold it for me. Now whenever we have a big family party, this is our must-make dessert.
Heavenly Ingredients
- Whipped topping: Gives the top a light, dreamy finish
- Instant chocolate pudding mix: Tosses together a fuss-free, thick topping
- Cold milk: Gets the pudding to the right creamy thickness
- Vanilla extract: Boosts the flavor of the creamy layer
- Ricotta cheese: Adds the dreamiest, slightly tangy middle
- Chocolate cake mix: And whatever the box asks for makes the bottom rich and chocolatey, all without extra dishes
- Eggs: Help everything set up nice and rich
- Granulated sugar: Sweetens things up perfectly so it never gets heavy or too sweet
Easy How-To Guide
- Finish Off With The Topping:
- Smooth the topping all over your cooled cake nice and even, swirl it for a bit of flair if you feel like it. Pop on some plastic wrap (just don’t let it stick to the frosting), and chill in the fridge for a good 4 hours—overnight is even better for max flavor.
- Whip Up The Topping:
- Dump the pudding mix and cold milk into a big bowl and whisk tough for 2 minutes. After about 5 minutes, it should thicken. Fold in the whipped topping with slow, wide swoops so it stays nice and airy.
- Bake It Right:
- Slide your pan onto the center rack. Bake for around 50-60 minutes, but peek in starting at 45 to check. If a toothpick in the middle comes out clean, you’re good. Let it cool completely on a rack for no less than 2 hours.
- Make The Ricotta Goodness:
- Beat up the ricotta for 2 minutes to knock out any lumps. Add each egg and mix before tossing in the next. Stir in sugar and vanilla until it just comes together. Spoon it gently in blobs over your cake batter, then spread lightly so it covers the whole thing.
- Mix Up The Cake Batter:
- Go by the box and mix with the eggs, oil, and water. Beat for a couple of minutes till smooth. Pour the batter in your greased dish and even out the top.
- Get The Oven Ready:
- Set your oven to 350°F, then grease your pan really well, making sure you hit all the edges. Toss in a sprinkle of flour if you want it extra nonstick.
Pin it
The ricotta really takes this dessert up a notch. My Italian neighbor swears by letting the ricotta drain in a mesh strainer covered with cheesecloth for a half hour before you use it. Honestly, it makes the texture so much better—you’ll be glad you did it.
Secret To Amazing Layers
The best part about this sweet treat is what happens in the oven. While it bakes, that creamy ricotta mixture sinks down and swaps places with the lighter cake batter, so you get those picture-perfect layers without any fancy steps. It’s basically science—one’s heavier and naturally settles, while the cake rises up. The final look is like you spent hours messing with it, but you hardly did anything!
Tasty Ways To Change It Up
Everyone goes wild for the classic chocolate version, but it’s super easy to swap flavors! Want something zesty? Use white cake mix and lemon pudding. Digging an Italian vibe? Try vanilla cake with pistachio pudding. Just don’t swap out the ricotta—it’s what brings the magic. I love making a red velvet one for Valentine’s Day—super cute!
How To Serve It Up
This dessert already looks great solo, but a few quick add-ons take it further. Toss some cocoa powder, chocolate curls, or crushed amaretti cookies over the top for a fancy look. Go all out with a bit of whipped cream and some berries on each slice. And it’s unbeatable with a cold glass of dessert wine or a hot espresso on the side—so good.
Storing It And Getting Ahead
Letting your Italian Love Cake chill for a while actually makes it even tastier. Just stash it in the fridge covered, and you’ve got five good days before it gets tired. Don’t try to freeze it though, since the topping and ricotta won’t hold up. If you’re making it for company, build the main part up to two days early, but save the pudding topping for the day before you serve, for the best look and taste.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → How does layering happen in Italian Love Cake?
As the cake bakes, the ricotta layer drops down while the chocolate layer rises. This creates a pretty layered design.
- → What chocolate cake mix is best to use?
Go for any regular chocolate cake mix, around 15.25 ounces. Just follow the package instructions for consistency.
- → Can the dessert be made early?
Absolutely. Make it at least 4 hours in advance or the night before serving for the best flavors and set layers.
- → Can ricotta be swapped with anything else?
Ricotta gives it the perfect texture, but mascarpone can work if you're looking for a richer alternative.
- → How do I store this cake?
Keep the cake covered in the fridge and enjoy it within 3 days for ultimate freshness.
- → Could I use a different pudding flavor?
Of course! Experiment with vanilla or other pudding flavors for a unique twist on the topping.