
Y'all, I've gotta tell you how much I love this. Paula’s corn casserole is always a crowd-pleaser. It takes hardly any time since you’ll just use Jiffy and a handful of simple stuff but the flavor makes folks think you went all out. I often bake it in the oven, but my slow cooker gets the job done just as well if I’m feeling lazy. This one works great whether it’s a holiday spread or a regular weeknight.
Why This Dish Always Delivers
This bake is all about cozy goodness. It turns out super creamy and cheesy, just how everybody likes it. You honestly can’t mess this up, even if you try. When I’m having people over, making it ahead saves the day. Toss it in the oven or let the Crock Pot do the work, either way the flavors are awesome and just keep getting better.
You're Gonna Need These Simple Ingredients
- Tangy Goodness: Go for a generous scoop of sour cream for some creamy tang.
- Creamy Corn: Grab a can of that thick creamed corn for smooth texture.
- Just The Best Mix: Trust me, Jiffy corn muffin mix brings it all together.
- Cheese On Top: Grated cheddar lifts the whole thing, don’t skip it.
- Crisp Kernels: Drain a can of sweet corn to add juicy bites.
- Rich Flavor: A nice chunk of butter helps everything come together.

Here's How to Whip It Up
- To Prep It Early
- You can put everything together and stash it in your fridge for up to two days. Let it warm up on the counter for half an hour before you bake. If you’ve already cooked it, just reheat at 300°F topped with new cheese, then bump up to 350°F until it looks perfect.
- Slow Cooker Method
- Dump all but the cheese in your oiled Crock Pot. Cook on high for 2 or 3 hours or switch to low for about 4. Toss in the cheese about 20 minutes before you’re done.
- Baking in the Oven
- Warm your oven to 350°F. Blend everything but cheese in one big bowl. Pour into a buttered dish and bake 45 minutes. Then throw cheese on top and bake 10-15 more minutes until bubbly and brown.
My Best Tips For Awesome Results
Grate up your own cheese for a smoother melt—it’s worth it. Craving more sweetness? Stir a couple spoons of sugar into your mix. Drain the sweet corn real well—too much liquid wrecks it. And once you get to the cheesy part, leave it uncovered so you get that golden top.
Great Pairings for This Dish
This goes with almost anything. I love putting it next to chili or crispy chicken for a chill night, or serve it with ham or roast on bigger occasions. Pop a salad or some steamed greens on the side and you’re all set.
How To Keep Leftovers Fresh
If you’ve got extra, toss them in an airtight container and they’ll be good in the fridge for three or four days. You can freeze it for up to three months, but honestly—it’s way tastier right out of the oven. Ready for round two? Just bake it at 350°F till it’s hot all the way through.

Frequently Asked Questions
- → Should I prepare the Jiffy mix beforehand?
- Nope, just toss the dry mix straight into the recipe. No pre-prepping needed.
- → Is it okay to make it early?
- Sure, either mix and chill before baking or bake fully and reheat when ready.
- → Can you freeze it?
- Yes, freeze tightly wrapped for three months. Let it thaw in the fridge before heating in the oven.
- → Why only drain the kernel corn?
- The creamed corn keeps it moist, whereas draining whole kernel corn avoids excess liquid.
- → Can I make it in a slow cooker?
- You can! On high, it’s done in 2-3 hours. Low takes 4. Add cheese about 20 minutes before finishing.