Pin it
For years now, I've been whipping up these cloud-soft Italian Christmas Cookies that always bring joy to everyone's face. They've got this gentle almond flavor, a sweet topping, and fun colorful sprinkles that really capture what holiday baking is all about. Though they're great for Christmas, these tasty little treats are way too good to only make once a year. I turn to them whenever I need something extra special for any occasion.
Why These Cookies Stand Out
Each mouthful of these cookies feels like you're enjoying a mini celebration. They've got an incredibly soft feel, almost like tiny cakes, with just enough almond or vanilla taste. The sweet topping creates the best base for bright sprinkles, giving you that satisfying little crunch. What I adore is how flexible they are—just change up the flavors and decorations and they'll work for any event.
Round Up Your Supplies
- All-Purpose Flour: Make sure to spoon and level your flour for that cake-like softness instead of dipping straight from the package.
- Baking Powder: This creates that wonderful puffiness and airy texture.
- Butter: Room temperature salted butter works best for me. If you've got unsalted, just add a small dash of salt.
- Eggs: Go with large eggs to get that soft, moist texture.
- Extracts: Pick what you like best—almond, vanilla, or try anise for a true Italian touch.
- Powdered Sugar: This makes the creamiest, most wonderful topping.
- Sprinkles: The tiny round ones are traditional, but any festive mix will look great.
Time To Make The Magic
- Get Your Dough Ready
- First, stir your baking powder into the flour and put it aside. Beat the butter till it's light, then add your eggs, sugar and whatever extract you picked. Slowly fold in your dry stuff. Let the dough cool in the fridge for at least 60 minutes.
- Form And Bake Your Cookies
- Roll the dough into small balls using a cookie scoop or regular tablespoon. Put them about an inch apart on baking sheets lined with parchment. Bake at 350°F for around 8-10 minutes until they're done and just turning golden on the bottom.
- Whip Up The Topping
- As they cool down, mix your topping with powdered sugar, extract and just a bit of milk until it's the right thickness. Dip each cool cookie, let extra drip off, then quickly add sprinkles before the topping hardens.
Insider Baking Secrets
Want to know how I get such soft cookies every time? Don't stir your dough too much—just until things come together. Cooling the dough isn't optional, it stops them from spreading too much. Always let your cookies cool completely before adding topping or it'll just slide right off. And if your dough gets sticky, a little cooking spray on your hands fixes that problem fast.
Switch Things Up
These cookies can transform for any event you've got coming up. Try them with lemon extract when spring arrives or use anise for that old-school Italian flavor. Swap out your sprinkles for smashed candy canes at Christmas or light pastel colors at Easter. They're basically waiting for you to get creative with them.
Storage Smarts
These little gems stay soft and yummy for up to seven days when kept in a sealed container at room temp. Need to make them ahead? Freeze them without topping in an airtight container for up to three months. Just thaw them out and add fresh topping and sprinkles when you're ready to enjoy them.
Tasty Companions
These cookies taste amazing with a big mug of hot cocoa when it's cold outside. They're also wonderful with your morning coffee or afternoon tea. When friends come over, I love putting them on a plate with chocolate mint cookies and spicy gingerbread for a really festive mix.
Fun With Kids
These treats are just right for small helpers in the kitchen. My children can't wait to cover them with different sprinkles and watch as the topping sets. It's become our holiday custom and the memories we create together mean more than any sweet treat ever could.
Timeless Holiday Favorites
These Italian Christmas Cookies go way beyond just being dessert. They're small bites of tradition that bring warmth to every holiday get-together. Their subtle sweetness and festive look make them hard for anyone to turn down. In my family, they've become a symbol of holiday love that we pass down through the years.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I swap out the almond extract?
- Of course! Use vanilla or anise extract instead. Each gives its own unique flavor.
- → Why should I chill the dough first?
- The dough gets less sticky and rolls better when chilled. It also keeps cookies from spreading while baking.
- → How do I know they’re ready?
- The cookies should be firm to the touch but not browned. They’ll still firm up as they cool, so don’t bake too long.
- → Can these cookies be frozen?
- Yes! Freeze before icing. Thaw fully at room temperature, then add the glaze and sprinkles before serving.
- → What’s the best way to store them?
- Keep them in an airtight container at room temp. If stacking, use wax paper between layers to protect the glaze.